top of page
Writer's pictureClive Cass

Incorporation relief: A case study

The recent uncertainty surrounding the proposed abolition of Furnished Holiday Lettings has led to property landlords considering whether they should incorporate their business. If an individual transfers their business to a limited company, incorporation relief may be available. However, it may be difficult to demonstrate that the activity constitutes a ‘business’.

What is incorporation relief?


If an individual (either a sole trader or in a partnership) transfers their business to a limited company, this is a ‘disposal’ for capital gains tax (CGT) purposes. Incorporation relief allows the individual to delay paying CGT by ‘rolling over’ the gain. This only applies when the individual receives shares in exchange for the business; incorporation relief does not apply to any proportion of the business exchanged for cash.

 

As an example, an individual incorporates his business and receives 1,000 shares in the new company and £20,000 cash. The market value of the business on incorporation was £100,000 and the chargeable gain that would have arisen without incorporation relief would have been £60,000.

 

The market value of each share would be £80. The part of the gain relating to shares is £48,000 (80% of £60,000); this part can be rolled over.

 

When he eventually disposes his shares in the company, their base cost will be £80,000 less the rolled over gain of £48,000, so £32,000.

 

On incorporation, the individual is liable to CGT on the cash portion of the gain: £60,000 less £48,000 = £12,000.

 

Could a property business qualify for incorporation relief?

Yes, it could. CGT legislation does not define ‘business’, nor does it define the difference between a business and a passive investment. In order to obtain incorporation relief, landlords should be able to demonstrate that they actively manage their portfolio. HMRC also consider the size of the property portfolio to be a key factor.


The Ramsay case

In 2013, the UK Upper Tribunal heard an appeal regarding the eligibility of a property letting business for incorporation relief (Elizabeth Moyne Ramsay v HMRC [2013] UKUT 0226). Mrs Ramsay’s case had previously been heard by the First Tier Tribunal, which had ruled that her property letting business was not a business for incorporation relief purposes.


Mrs Ramsay owned and managed a small apartment building and spent around 20 hours per week maintaining the building and dealing with potential and existing tenants.


The Upper Tribunal found that the First Tier Tribunal had erred by considering case law that was not relevant to the matter in hand. It was found that for CGT purposes, the word ‘business’ has a very broad meaning and that the Tribunal should consider whether Mrs Ramsay’s activities were:


·        A serious undertaking or operation that is earnestly pursued;

·        Actively pursued with recognisable continuity;

·        Of substance in terms of turnover;

·        Conducted in a regular manner on sound and recognised business principles; and

·        Of a kind commonly made by those who seek to profit from them.


On this basis, the Tribunal found that Mrs Ramsay’s activities amounted to more than would normally be expected of a passive investor so she was running a business for the purposes of CGT and was therefore entitled to incorporation relief.


Further information 

HMRC’s overview of incorporation relief can be read here: https://www.gov.uk/incorporation-relief

The Upper Tribunal ruling referred to in this factsheet can be viewed here: http://taxandchancery_ut.decisions.tribunals.gov.uk/Documents/decisions/Elisabeth_Moyne_Ramsay_v_HMRC.pdf

 

6 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

VAT: Option to Tax

Option to Tax is a frequently misunderstood VAT topic. Opting to tax land and buildings can be beneficial in many cases, but there are...

Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings (ATED)

If you are considering incorporating your property business, one of the considerations should be Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings...

Comments


bottom of page